Falcon rocket ‘close call’: How ISRO prevented space disaster

In a rare display of international collaboration and stringent safety oversight, the Indian Space Research Organisation (ISRO) played a decisive role in averting what could have been a catastrophic failure aboard SpaceX’s Falcon‑9 rocket on June 11, 2025. A critical crack in the oxidizer line of the first stage, which threatened the lives of four astronauts on the Axiom‑4 mission, was detected only after ISRO Chairman Dr. V. Narayanan insisted on a heightened review—prompting additional inspections that uncovered the flaw just hours before liftoff ndtv.comtimesofindia.indiatimes.com.

Expertise in Action

Dr. V. Narayanan, Distinguished Scientist (Apex Grade) and newly appointed ISRO Chairman (effective January 14, 2025), has over four decades of experience in rocket and spacecraft propulsion, including leadership roles on Chandrayaan and GSLV programmes. He holds an MTech in Cryogenic Engineering (First Rank, IIT Kharagpur) and a PhD in Aerospace Engineering from IIT Kharagpur. As Director of ISRO’s Liquid Propulsion Systems Centre (2018–2025), he oversaw the development of India’s cryogenic engine technology isro.gov.in.

Timeline of a Near‑Miss

• June 10, 2025, 09:00 UTC + 5:30: SpaceX engineers begin routine pre‑launch checks at Cape Canaveral.
• June 10, 17:30 UTC + 5:30: Dr. Narayanan, having been briefed on preliminary data from SpaceX, requests a “demand for due diligence”—calling for an exhaustive review of all propulsion lines.
• June 10, 23:00 UTC + 5:30: Additional non‑destructive testing reveals a 2 mm crack in a first‑stage oxidizer feed line.
• June 11, 02:15 UTC + 5:30: SpaceX grounds the launch, replaces the damaged line, and conducts pressure and flow‑rate tests.
• June 11, 11:45 UTC + 5:30: Falcon‑9 successfully lifts off, carrying four astronauts to the International Space Station.

5 Key Takeaways

1. Proactive Safety Oversight
   ISRO’s insistence on extra checks—beyond SpaceX’s standard protocol—was instrumental in identifying the flaw. This underscores the value of independent safety audits in multinational missions timesofindia.indiatimes.com.
2. Importance of Redundancy
   The oxidizer line in question had a parallel feed line designed to maintain pressure, which bought engineers crucial time for diagnosis and repair.
3. Rapid Response and Repair
   SpaceX’s ground crew replaced the defective line and requalified the entire stage within 12 hours. Such agility highlights robust contingency planning.
4. Global Collaboration
   The Axiom‑4 mission, a U.S.–Indian collaboration, exemplifies how sharing expertise across agencies can enhance crew safety and mission success.
5. Engineers’ Vigilance
   Even minor manufacturing defects can have outsized consequences—reminding the aerospace community that no detail is too small for inspection.

Expert Analysis

“A crack of this size in an oxidizer line can rapidly propagate under cryogenic conditions, leading to sudden loss of thrust or in‑flight explosion,” explains Dr. Jonathan McDowell, astrophysicist at Harvard University, via email. “Early detection is vital; this incident serves as a case study in the critical importance of multi‑agency reviews.”

What Happens Next?

• Ongoing Axiom‑4 Updates: The crew is on schedule to dock with the ISS on June 19, 2025.
• Post‑Flight Review: ISRO and SpaceX will co‑host a joint failure investigation board in July 2025 to analyze root causes and refine protocols.
• Future Protocols: NASA is reportedly considering adopting similar independent diligence demands for all upcoming commercial crew launches.

Daily Digest

Stay informed with our ongoing coverage of the Axiom‑4 mission:

• June 19: ISS docking and initial health check of crew.
• June 22: First spacewalk planned to install new research modules.
• June 28: Scheduled return to Earth aboard Crew Dragon.

Fact‑Check